Combating concentration

Competition Authority Moves to Block Gadot and Dor Chemicals at Haifa Port

An opinion submitted to Israel Ports Company calls for bringing in an outside operator for the country's only public facility • At the same time, it was proposed that private storage tanks also be opened to third-party use

Haifa Port
Haifa Port | Photo: Yonatan Sindel, Flash90

Israel Competition Authority is taking a stand against the powerful players in the chemicals industry. The competition commissioner submitted an official opinion to Israel Ports Company (IPC), explicitly recommending that Gadot Group and Dor Chemicals be barred in advance from participating in the construction and operation of the new public chemicals terminal at Haifa Port's northern terminal.

Michal Cohen, Israel Competition Authority. Photo: Yonatan Sindel, Flash90
Michal Cohen, head of Israel Competition Authority | Photo: Flash90

This position was submitted under the commissioner's authority pursuant to the chapter on sectoral concentration in the Concentration Law, even before the official tender was issued.

A critical bottleneck for the Israeli economy

The new terminal in the northern part of the port is intended to replace the southern terminal, which is expected to close soon because of regulatory changes. This is an irreplaceable strategic infrastructure asset, as the new terminal is expected to operate as Israel's only universal public terminal for unloading, loading and storing chemicals imported by bulk carriers into shore tanks.

Chemicals plant
Chemicals plant | Photo: Shutterstock

Control of an asset of this kind provides enormous influence over the supply chain for raw materials essential to a range of industries in Israel.

Concern over dual harm: horizontal and vertical

In examining the implications of the tender, Israel Competition Authority identified two main risks. From a horizontal perspective, Gadot and Dor Chemicals already own private shore tanks at the northern terminal, and awarding the concession to operate the public terminal to either of them would eliminate an existing or potential competitor in unloading and storage.

Haifa Port
Haifa Port | Photo: Shutterstock

From a vertical perspective, Gadot Group is a dominant trader in the liquid chemicals market. Israel Competition Authority is concerned that control of the public terminal could be used to block competing traders or thwart independent imports by end customers, thereby strengthening or entrenching the group's market power in the trading segment.

Preference for a new player and requirement for further consultation

In light of these risks, the commissioner recommends entrusting the project to a new player that is not currently active at the northern terminal and does not trade chemicals on a significant scale.

The commissioner emphasizes that preference should be given to bidders with professional qualifications and no business ties to trade in the sector.

Chemicals in a test tube, illustration
Chemicals in a test tube, illustration | Photo: Shutterstock

In addition, IPC is required to consult Israel Competition Authority again after receiving the bids in the tender, to reassess the identities of the bidders. This position follows the authority's determination in 2018 that Gadot's operation of the current southern terminal causes significant harm to competition.

Opening existing tanks to outside use

Alongside setting the tender terms, the commissioner presented a complementary measure aimed at expanding competition in the immediate term.

Currently, the companies that own private shore tanks at the northern terminal are permitted to unload materials solely for their own use.

Containers at Haifa Port
Containers at Haifa Port | Photo: Yaakov Naumi, Flash90

The commissioner recommends amending their authorization documents to allow them to provide unloading services to third parties as well, a step that would create additional alternatives for private importers and independent traders.

Key takeaways

  • The Israel Competition Authority recommended that Gadot Group and Dor Chemicals be barred in advance from bidding on the new public chemicals terminal at Haifa Port’s northern terminal.
  • The authority said the new terminal is intended to replace the southern terminal and become Israel’s only universal public terminal for unloading, loading and storing imported chemicals.
  • It warned of both horizontal harm, because Gadot and Dor already own private shore tanks at the northern terminal, and vertical harm, because Gadot is a dominant trader in liquid chemicals.
  • The commissioner also said IPC should consult the authority again after bids are received to reassess the identities of the bidders.
  • As a complementary step, the authority recommended allowing private shore-tank owners at the northern terminal to provide unloading services to third parties, not only for their own use.

Questions and answers

Why does the Competition Authority want to block Gadot and Dor Chemicals from the Haifa Port tender?
The authority says both companies already own private shore tanks at the northern terminal, so giving them the public terminal could eliminate a competitor in unloading and storage. It also worries that control of the terminal could strengthen Gadot’s market power in liquid chemicals trading.
What is special about the new chemicals terminal at Haifa Port?
According to the article, it is meant to replace the southern terminal and become Israel’s only universal public terminal for unloading, loading and storing chemicals imported by bulk carriers into shore tanks. The authority describes it as a strategic infrastructure asset with major influence over supply chains.
What additional step did the commissioner propose to increase competition sooner?
The commissioner proposed amending the authorization documents of private shore-tank owners at the northern terminal so they can unload materials for third parties as well. That would create more options for private importers and independent traders.

Share this story

About the writer

Shai Nogai

Writes for TV10, Israel’s economic channel. This story was translated from the original Hebrew.

More stories by Shai Nogai

More for you