Tech

Clash escalates: OpenAI vs. Apple — trying to blame others for their failures

OpenAI
OpenAI | Photo: Shutterstock

The legal battle between the two technology giants escalated further after OpenAI filed a sharply worded response with the U.S. District Court in California, according to Reuters.

In the defense filing, the ChatGPT developer categorically rejected Apple’s allegations that it stole trade secrets and accused the iPhone maker of trying to block free competition and undermine legitimate employee mobility. OpenAI said the lawsuit was nothing more than an attempt by Apple to conceal its internal failures and the negligent practices it had itself implemented.

It allowed employees to do it, then blamed them: OpenAI’s defense

At the heart of the legal response is the claim that Apple itself created the confusion and chaos surrounding the confidential information. According to OpenAI, Apple encouraged its employees over the years to use private iCloud accounts to manage work documents and corporate information, making it impossible to separate personal and commercial materials when their employment ended.

Apple | Photo: Shutterstock

In addition, OpenAI claimed that Apple’s policy of immediately escorting employees out of its offices does not give them reasonable time to return equipment or transfer materials in an orderly manner, after which it chooses to accuse them of retaining information.

From shared technology to bitter rivalry: The background to the legal battle

The current lawsuit, originally filed by Apple in July, marks the deterioration in relations between the two companies, which only two years ago signed a strategic cooperation agreement to integrate OpenAI’s AI into Apple devices.

Tensions grew after OpenAI began expanding into hardware and recruited about 400 former Apple employees, including former senior executives such as Tang Tan and Chang Liu.

Lawsuit illustration | Photo: Shutterstock

Apple claimed that the hires were part of a planned strategy to extract manufacturing and supply chain secrets, while OpenAI noted that California state law explicitly protects employees’ freedom to move between competing companies.

Key takeaways

  • OpenAI filed a strong response in the U.S. District Court in California, escalating its legal fight with Apple.
  • OpenAI rejected Apple’s claims that it stole trade secrets and said Apple is trying to block free competition and legitimate employee mobility.
  • OpenAI argued that Apple’s own policies around private iCloud accounts and quickly escorting employees out of offices created confusion over confidential information.
  • Apple’s original lawsuit, filed in July, came after relations between the companies deteriorated despite a strategic cooperation agreement signed two years ago.
  • Apple alleged that OpenAI’s hiring of about 400 former Apple employees was part of a plan to extract manufacturing and supply chain secrets.

Questions and answers

What is OpenAI saying in response to Apple’s lawsuit?
OpenAI denied Apple’s trade secret theft allegations and said the lawsuit is an attempt to conceal Apple’s internal failures. It also accused Apple of trying to block free competition and legitimate employee movement between companies.
Why does OpenAI say Apple is responsible for the information problem?
OpenAI says Apple encouraged employees to use private iCloud accounts for work documents and corporate information, which blurred personal and business materials. It also says Apple’s practice of immediately escorting employees out of offices leaves them no reasonable time to return equipment or transfer materials properly.
What is the background to the dispute between Apple and OpenAI?
The lawsuit was originally filed by Apple in July after the relationship between the companies deteriorated. The article says they had signed a strategic cooperation agreement two years ago to integrate OpenAI’s AI into Apple devices.

Share this story

About the writer

Shay Nogai

Writes for TV10, Israel’s economic channel. This story was translated from the original Hebrew.

More stories by Shay Nogai

More for you