Backing From the Top

AI on Trial: Trump Administration Sides With OpenAI in The New York Times' Massive Lawsuit

OpenAI
OpenAI | Photo: Shutterstock

The U.S. administration filed a legal brief with the federal court in Manhattan in response to The New York Times' copyright infringement lawsuit against OpenAI and Microsoft, Reuters reported.

Sam Altman, CEO of OpenAI
Sam Altman, CEO of OpenAI | Photo: Shutterstock

In its official position, the administration argued that training large language models on copyrighted content is generally considered “fair use.” This is the U.S. administration’s first intervention in the wave of lawsuits sweeping the industry, a move that analysts say could provide a significant boost to technology companies.

National Security and Scientific Progress Versus Claims of Theft

The government’s reasoning stated that the U.S. has a clear interest in rejecting claims that training the models violates the law, particularly because of considerations involving scientific progress and national security.

Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward made clear that the administration would not allow the country to fall behind foreign rivals because of what it considers an erroneous interpretation of copyright laws.

Courtroom, illustration
Courtroom, illustration | Photo: Shutterstock

At the same time, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick called on G20 countries to adopt an approach that allows artificial intelligence to be trained on creative works while finding ways to protect artists. The New York Times, however, criticized the move, arguing that the administration was choosing to side with giant corporations at the expense of creators whose livelihoods had been taken away.

The Legal Battle Over the Definition of “Fair Use”

The New York Times' lawsuit, filed in 2023, is part of dozens of legal proceedings currently underway against technology giants such as OpenAI, Anthropic and Meta.

The central issue at stake is whether using copyrighted information to generate new content is considered fair and transformative use. While different judges have already issued conflicting rulings on the matter over the past year, the U.S. administration stated in its position that the technology does indeed change the landscape in an extraordinary way.

Language models | Photo: Shutterstock

According to the administration’s position, hindering the development of the models would impede scientific breakthroughs and harm U.S. economic growth.

Key takeaways

  • The U.S. administration filed a legal brief in Manhattan responding to The New York Times' copyright lawsuit against OpenAI and Microsoft.
  • The administration said training large language models on copyrighted content is generally considered “fair use.”
  • It was the first intervention by the U.S. administration in the wave of AI-related lawsuits facing the industry.
  • The government argued that restricting model training could hurt scientific progress, national security, and U.S. economic growth.
  • The New York Times said the administration was siding with giant corporations at the expense of creators.

Questions and answers

What did the U.S. administration say about training AI models on copyrighted content?
It argued that training large language models on copyrighted content is generally considered “fair use.” The administration said this position reflects U.S. interests in scientific progress and national security.
Which lawsuit is this connected to?
The brief was filed in response to The New York Times' copyright infringement lawsuit against OpenAI and Microsoft, filed in 2023. The article says this case is part of dozens of similar legal proceedings against technology companies.
Why does the administration say this matters?
The administration said that blocking model training could slow scientific breakthroughs and harm U.S. economic growth. Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward also said the U.S. should not fall behind foreign rivals.

Share this story

About the writer

Shay Nogai

Writes for TV10, Israel’s economic channel. This story was translated from the original Hebrew.

More stories by Shay Nogai

More for you