Breaking

Token Price Plunge Raises Concerns: Is Anthropic Stock Under Threat?

Anthropic ended its first day of trading on Nasdaq up 17%, but concerns are mounting over its business model: Token prices have plunged by more than 40% within months, while competition from cheaper AI models is intensifying • Is this a positive development that lowers operating costs, or a warning sign for investors?

Dario Amodei, CEO of Anthropic
Dario Amodei, CEO of Anthropic | Photo: Shutterstock

The initial public offering of Anthropic (ANT) was one of the year’s biggest capital market events. The artificial intelligence company received an enthusiastic welcome on Wall Street, and its stock jumped 17% on its first day of trading. But behind the excitement over the offering, skeptical voices are also beginning to emerge, raising questions about the company’s ability to maintain a competitive advantage and remain profitable over time.

One of the main concerns involves the plunge in token prices — the units of information that artificial intelligence models use to process and generate text. According to the Silicon Data LLM Token Expenditure Index, which weights token spending relative to usage volume, the effective price per million tokens fell by more than 40% between the end of June and the beginning of October, and the trend continued afterward.

Anthropic
Anthropic | Photo: Shutterstock

The pressure is also evident in the pricing of Anthropic’s own services. The company cut the price of its new flagship model, Fable 5.2, by 20%. For consumers and business customers, this is a positive development that reduces the cost of using the technology.

For investors, however, the question is whether the decline in prices stems from technological efficiency gains or from intensifying competition that is forcing the company to forgo revenue.

Not Just Efficiency: Competition Is Pressuring Prices

There are several explanations for the decline in token prices. First, competition from cheaper models is putting pressure on prices across the industry. Second, customers are changing their usage patterns and shifting more routine and simple tasks to cheaper models instead of using the most advanced and expensive models.

In addition, the cost of generating tokens is falling thanks to improvements in computing efficiency and infrastructure utilization. Such efficiency gains allow companies to offer lower prices without necessarily hurting their profitability.

However, the concern is that cheaper services will not necessarily translate into a significant increase in usage. Bloomberg Chief Economist Anna Wong noted that token prices had fallen sharply, but Anthropic’s share of usage did not grow accordingly and even recorded a certain decline. She said this could indicate a market structure in which companies lack significant pricing power over time, forcing them to cut prices and increase activity levels to continue growing.

Anthropic management at Nasdaq — initial public offering
Anthropic management at Nasdaq — initial public offering | Photo: Reuters

Does Anthropic Have a Sustainable Competitive Advantage?

Criticism of Anthropic is not limited to token prices. Opponents of investing in the company argue that it is struggling to establish a competitive advantage that would protect it from rivals offering cheaper models. One risk is a process known as Distillation, in which smaller and cheaper models learn to imitate the capabilities of advanced models, allowing competitors to offer similar performance at a lower price.

On the other hand, the decline in prices does not necessarily indicate damage to profitability. If computing costs fall faster than service prices, Anthropic may continue to improve its profit margins even in a competitive environment. According to The Motley Fool’s analysis, the company’s profitability has actually improved despite the decline in token prices.

Anthropic logo alongside dollars, illustration
Anthropic logo alongside dollars, illustration | Photo: Shutterstock

Anthropic’s offering therefore presents investors with a significant dilemma: On the one hand, it is a company operating in a market with enormous potential and growing demand for AI technologies. On the other hand, it is unclear how well it will be able to maintain its pricing power in a world where cheaper models are becoming available and improving rapidly.

Anthropic’s long-term success will be measured not only by its technological capabilities or the level of demand for its models, but also by its ability to turn growth into revenue and profits — without having to resort to relentless price cuts.

Key takeaways

  • Anthropic’s IPO was one of the year’s biggest capital market events, and the stock rose 17% on its first day of trading.
  • A key concern is that the effective price per million tokens fell by more than 40% between the end of June and the beginning of October, with the trend continuing afterward.
  • Anthropic cut the price of its new flagship model, Fable 5.2, by 20%, which helps customers but raises questions for investors about pricing power and revenue.
  • The article says cheaper models, changing customer usage patterns, and efficiency gains are all contributing to lower token prices.
  • The company’s long-term success will depend on whether it can turn growth into revenue and profits without relying on repeated price cuts.

Questions and answers

Why are investors worried about Anthropic after its IPO?
The article says investors are concerned that falling token prices may reflect intensifying competition rather than just efficiency gains. That could make it harder for Anthropic to preserve pricing power, revenue growth, and long-term profitability.
How much have token prices fallen?
According to the Silicon Data LLM Token Expenditure Index, the effective price per million tokens fell by more than 40% between the end of June and the beginning of October, and the decline continued afterward.
Does lower pricing necessarily hurt Anthropic’s profitability?
Not necessarily. The article says if computing costs fall faster than service prices, Anthropic could still improve its profit margins, and The Motley Fool’s analysis said profitability has actually improved despite the price decline.

Share this story

About the writer

TV10 Desk

Writes for TV10, Israel’s economic channel. This story was translated from the original Hebrew.

More stories by TV10 Desk

More for you