Breaking

Meta to Pay $25 Billion Fine for Misleading the Public

A New Mexico court ruled that Meta misled the public about how it handled Facebook users' personal information and addressed harmful content • The company plans to appeal: "It is nearly impossible to do business in the state"

The Meta logo
The Meta logo | Photo: Shutterstock

Meta, which owns Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, was fined $25 billion in a case involving user privacy and misleading the public. A judge in the US state of New Mexico ruled Wednesday that the company had violated state laws for more than a decade and misled the public about how Facebook users' personal information was collected, used and shared.

The fine was imposed following a two-week trial earlier this year. The jury found that Meta violated state laws more than 40 million times, including through misleading representations about the protection of user data and the handling of content containing hate speech. According to Judge Francis Mathew, the violations were intentional and continued from 2010 to 2021.

In his ruling, the judge wrote that communications among company executives, including CEO Mark Zuckerberg, were intended to mislead the public. He said the deception was not limited to Facebook's privacy policy but also concerned the core of the company's business operations.

The Cambridge Analytica Scandal in the Background

The New Mexico lawsuit is connected, among other things, to the Cambridge Analytica scandal, in which the information and data of millions of Facebook users were used as part of political consulting activity. The affair sparked widespread public criticism, partly over the use of data linked to the 2016 US presidential election, which Donald Trump won for the first time.

The lawsuit alleged that over the years, Meta represented that users' personal information was not shared with outside parties and that they were not given access to it without users' consent, while in practice the information was exposed to third parties.

Meta founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg
Meta founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg | Photo: Shutterstock

In addition, the state accused the company of misleading the public about how it benefits from content containing hate speech and how rules against such content are enforced. The jury also accepted these claims.

According to the state's attorneys, New Mexico's entire population of about 2 million people was affected by the deception regarding how Meta managed user data.

Meta to Appeal: "It Is Nearly Impossible to Do Business in the State"

Meta rejected the allegations against it and said it intends to appeal the ruling. The company's chief legal officer, C.J. Mahoney, argued that the decision makes doing business in New Mexico “nearly impossible.” He said the lawsuit effectively seeks to impose a tax on free speech in order to enforce new rules concerning what people can say online.

The lawsuit asked the court to impose fines of up to $40 billion on the company, while Meta argued that a fine exceeding $3.4 billion would be unconstitutional.

Court, illustration
Court, illustration | Photo: Shutterstock

The judge calculated the scope of the violations at $219 billion but reduced the fine to $25 billion. According to the report, the amount set is similar to the company's profit in a single quarter.

A Year of Legal Battles

The ruling joins a series of legal proceedings in which Meta has been involved this year. In 2019, the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) imposed a $5 billion fine on the company for violations related to user privacy.

New Mexico also pursued a separate case against the company this year, in which Meta was fined nearly $1 billion following allegations that it misled the public about the safety of its platforms for children.

Meta
Meta | Photo: Shutterstock

At the same time, Meta and several US states reached a settlement in a lawsuit involving allegations of harm to children and insufficient safeguards on the company's social networks. The settlement was reached days after the trial began, did not include a fine and did not include an admission of liability by Meta.

The current lawsuit sharpens the legal pressure on the technology giant over its handling of personal information, transparency with users and responsibility for content distributed on the platforms it owns.

Key takeaways

  • A New Mexico judge ruled that Meta must pay a $25 billion fine after finding the company misled the public about Facebook users' personal information and harmful content.
  • The jury found Meta violated state laws more than 40 million times, and Judge Francis Mathew said the violations were intentional and lasted from 2010 to 2021.
  • The ruling is tied in part to the Cambridge Analytica scandal and allegations that Facebook user data was shared with third parties without consent.
  • Meta said it will appeal, with chief legal officer C.J. Mahoney arguing that doing business in New Mexico is “nearly impossible.”
  • The judge calculated the scope of the violations at $219 billion but reduced the penalty to $25 billion.

Questions and answers

Why was Meta fined $25 billion in New Mexico?
A judge ruled that Meta violated state laws for more than a decade and misled the public about how Facebook users' personal information was collected, used and shared. The jury also found misleading conduct involving harmful content and hate speech.
What is the Cambridge Analytica connection?
The lawsuit is connected in part to the Cambridge Analytica scandal, in which data from millions of Facebook users was used in political consulting. The article says the case also involved criticism over data tied to the 2016 US presidential election.
Will Meta appeal the ruling?
Yes. Meta said it intends to appeal, and its chief legal officer said the ruling makes doing business in New Mexico “nearly impossible.”

Share this story

About the writer

TV10 Desk

Writes for TV10, Israel’s economic channel. This story was translated from the original Hebrew.

More stories by TV10 Desk

More for you