Opinion

Markets in No-Man’s Land: Inflation Is Falling, but Interest Rates Could Rise

A gap has emerged between U.S. inflation data and falling oil prices, making it difficult for investors to understand where the markets are headed • Concerns about sticky price increases and further interest rate hikes could keep yields high for longer — and increase capital market volatility | Analysis

Will the interest rate rise?
Will the interest rate rise? | Photo: Shutterstock

The global capital market is currently at an interesting crossroads — what should it “trust”? Past data or indications about the future? Between them lies what I call a “no-man’s land.” I am referring here to the key question: Where is inflation headed? And consequently, where are interest rates headed?

The U.S. Consumer Price Index (CPI) for October and the market’s response to it provide an excellent example of the dilemma.

On the face of it, the data released point to one clear conclusion — inflation is high, is not declining and is certainly not converging toward the 2% target level that the Federal Reserve is determined to achieve.

Interest rate
Interest rate | Photo: Shutterstock

Admittedly, this time the figure released does not show how much the Consumer Price Index (CPI) rose over the past 12 months. However, the index’s monthly increase — particularly the index excluding food and energy, which more accurately reflects demand within the U.S. economy, with an emphasis on service components — was higher than market expectations.

In today’s market environment, with sensitivity so high, every upside miss of one-tenth is a catalyst for declines in government bonds, causing their yields to rise and, beyond that, increasing the cost of raising capital and obtaining credit for households and companies.

This miss alone drove increases of 16 basis points and 10 basis points in the yields on the 3-year and 10-year bonds, respectively. That is a great deal for a single day. In the case of the latter, the 5% threshold once again appears very close. True, its yield stood at 5.3% only recently and has since fallen sharply, but now, as noted, it is rising again.

As a result, the market is pricing in a near-certain probability that the Federal Reserve’s interest rate will rise by 1/4% next month and, for the first time, there is a chance that it will also rise by 1/2%. One senior Fed official who spoke recently did not rule out this possibility outright.

U.S. inflation, illustration
U.S. inflation, illustration | Photo: Shutterstock

Remarkably, all this is happening as signs of calm emerge — as of this writing — around the conflict in the Middle East, driving a sharp decline in oil prices, whose surge since March led to a jump in inflation rates worldwide.

In the past week alone, the price of a barrel of Brent crude oil — a market benchmark — fell 11.4%. True, the price is still 42% above its level a year ago, and its volatility remains high, but this is nevertheless a sharp retreat that, if it continues and becomes established, could reduce both the actual inflation rate and inflation expectations.

So, looking ahead, which force will prevail?

First, it should be noted that even a sharp decline in crude oil prices, if it continues, will not immediately lead to a decline in the energy components of the Consumer Price Index (CPI), because the previous increases have meanwhile filtered through to production and refining processes, whose prices will respond much more slowly.

In addition, energy prices are not the whole picture, and high inflation also reflects price increases in services and nontradable goods. These are the components that the interest rate is intended to address, and as long as they remain “sticky,” the interest rate will struggle to fall, even if economic performance is lackluster and requires support.

Considering this, and in light of the inflation surges of the past decade — following the emergence from the COVID-19 pandemic, the outbreak of the war between Russia and Ukraine, and the conflict with Iran and the Houthis — central banks will likely need additional time and further examination of incoming data before deciding one way or the other. Until then, they will exercise greater caution.

Therefore, an apparently “strange” scenario of interest rate hikes alongside falling oil prices could continue, at least for a while. This is a situation the market will have to navigate, and it could produce higher-than-usual volatility.

And what should the market do in the meantime? Behave similarly and exercise caution. In particular, as long as inflation remains significantly above the target level in countries around the world — not the case in Israel, but the case in most developed countries, particularly the U.S. — interest rates are rising — again, with the exception of Israel — and many governments are running deficit budgets with heavy debt and borrowing needs, it is reasonable to estimate that market interest rates, across all maturities, will remain higher for longer.

Key takeaways

  • U.S. October CPI data came in above market expectations, reinforcing concerns that inflation remains high and is not converging to the Federal Reserve’s 2% target.
  • The market reacted with higher government bond yields, including a 16 basis point rise in the 3-year yield and a 10 basis point rise in the 10-year yield.
  • Markets are pricing in a near-certain 1/4% Fed rate hike next month, and for the first time a 1/2% increase is also being considered.
  • Brent crude fell 11.4% in the past week, but the article says falling oil prices may take time to filter through to CPI and inflation expectations.
  • The article argues that sticky services inflation and ongoing deficit spending could keep market interest rates higher for longer, increasing volatility.

Questions and answers

Why did markets react negatively to the U.S. CPI data?
Because the monthly CPI increase, especially the core measure excluding food and energy, was above market expectations. The article says that in today’s sensitive market, even a small upside miss pushes government bond prices down and yields up.
What does the article say about the Federal Reserve’s next move?
The market is pricing in a near-certain 1/4% rate hike next month. For the first time, there is also a chance of a 1/2% increase, and one senior Fed official did not rule that out.
Can lower oil prices reduce inflation quickly?
Not immediately, according to the article. It says previous energy price increases have already passed through production and refining, so the CPI response will be slower even if oil keeps falling.

Share this story

About the writer

Ronen Menachem

Writes for TV10, Israel’s economic channel. This story was translated from the original Hebrew.

More stories by Ronen Menachem

More for you