Opinion

Is Nvidia Too Big to Fail? How Huang's Drama Will Play Out in Markets

The chipmaker sells the processors on which data centers are built while helping its customers finance their construction • Its commitments are estimated at about $400 billion • Who will absorb the loss if Nvidia runs into trouble? | Analysis

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang at the annual GTC conference
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang at the annual GTC conference | Photo: Reuters

Nvidia shares are now trading more than 30% below the record high they reached only at the beginning of last month, and as the company's board addresses allegations concerning CEO Jensen Huang, a question the Federal Reserve examined as early as July, well before the current crisis, is back on the table: If the wave of investment in artificial intelligence comes to a halt, and against the backdrop of the “circular economy” at whose center Nvidia stands — having also disclosed in July commitments to purchase up to $36 billion in cloud services from its customers — will the losses also spill over to the banks and institutions that lent money to the industry?

Jensen Huang and his wife, Lori
Jensen Huang and his wife, Lori | Photo: Image Press Agency via Reuters Connect

The purchase of cloud services disclosed in July is only the tip of the iceberg of Nvidia's commitments. The company provided a tiered, conditional $105 billion guarantee for an OpenAI and SB Energy data center project in Ohio and committed to back up to $125 billion under a credit program from Wall Street financial institutions. According to estimates, its total commitments amount to about $400 billion.

What Must Happen for the Loss to Reach Lenders?

As long as Nvidia fulfills its purchase commitments and the cloud provider generates enough revenue to service the debt, a decline in Nvidia shares alone will leave the loss with shareholders. But what happens in a scenario in which Nvidia struggles to meet its commitments? The cloud provider could lose revenue it relied on when raising the debt, and if demand for computing power also weakens at the same time, that provider will find it harder to secure an alternative customer, while the decline in the value of the processors it holds will reduce the amount it can receive from selling them. In other words, once cloud providers struggle to repay their debt, the banks and private credit funds that lent to them could also absorb losses.

Nvidia and CoreWeave | Shutterstock. Processing: Created by AI
Nvidia and CoreWeave | Photo: Shutterstock. Processing: Created by AI

As noted, the commitments also include guarantees totaling hundreds of billions of dollars, although Columbia University Professor Stijn Van Nieuwerburgh estimates that Nvidia “would have to reach the brink of collapse” for all the guarantees to be at risk.

Is Nvidia Really Too Big to Fail?

In the banking sense, the answer from Sheila Bair, former chair of the U.S. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, is no. For a bank, a loss of confidence can quickly turn into deposit withdrawals, or a “bank run,” but Nvidia has a large capital base and a product that customers still want to buy.

However, one scenario worrying regulators is that same decline in the value of the processors, which would make it harder for cloud providers to repay the loans they took out to purchase them. Those losses could spill over to the banks and private credit funds that financed the transactions. The bond market is also more exposed to the industry. According to the International Monetary Fund, cloud giants' share of investment-grade bond issuance rose from 1% to 10% within two years. The Fed discussed as early as July the possibility that difficulties in the industry could trigger a broad repricing of assets.

Artificial intelligence, illustration
Artificial intelligence, illustration | Photo: Shutterstock

Signs of pressure are already emerging in the debt market. The cost of insurance against a CoreWeave default rose 94% between October 1 and November 5, while an IREN convertible bond lost 23% between November 3 and November 5. Before the Jensen Huang controversy erupted, shares of most smaller cloud providers had actually recovered this week, even as Nvidia continued to decline. For now, at least, investors view the Jensen Huang affair as an Nvidia crisis, and analysts still expect Nvidia's revenue to more than double in the current fiscal year and double again over the following two years.

Key takeaways

  • Nvidia shares are trading more than 30% below the record high reached at the beginning of last month.
  • The article says Nvidia disclosed in July commitments to purchase up to $36 billion in cloud services from customers and also has larger guarantees and credit-related commitments.
  • Nvidia provided a tiered, conditional $105 billion guarantee for an OpenAI and SB Energy data center project in Ohio and committed to back up to $125 billion under a credit program from Wall Street financial institutions.
  • According to estimates in the article, Nvidia's total commitments amount to about $400 billion.
  • The main risk discussed is that if Nvidia cannot meet its commitments and cloud demand weakens, losses could spread from cloud providers to banks and private credit funds.

Questions and answers

How much are Nvidia's commitments estimated to be?
According to the article, Nvidia's total commitments amount to about $400 billion. These include cloud-service purchases, a guarantee for an OpenAI and SB Energy project, and backing under a Wall Street credit program.
Who could absorb losses if Nvidia runs into trouble?
If Nvidia struggles to meet its commitments and cloud providers cannot repay debt, the article says banks and private credit funds that lent to them could also absorb losses. The bond market is also described as more exposed to the industry.
Is Nvidia considered too big to fail in the banking sense?
The article quotes Sheila Bair, former chair of the U.S. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, saying the answer is no in the banking sense. Nvidia has a large capital base and a product customers still want to buy, unlike a bank run scenario.

Share this story

About the writer

Sharon Birkman

Writes for TV10, Israel’s economic channel. This story was translated from the original Hebrew.

More stories by Sharon Birkman

More for you